Runout vs Concentricity: Which Callout Fits a Shaft
Runout vs concentricity: runout is a fast indicator check on a spinning surface, concentricity needs a CMM. Why half the runout isn't the concentricity.
Two people can argue over the same shaft drawing for an hour, and runout vs concentricity is usually where it starts. One says concentricity is just half the runout reading. The other says they aren't the same thing at all.
Is Concentricity the Same as Runout, and Can You Measure It With an Indicator?
No. Runout is a surface control you check with a dial indicator while the part spins on its datum axis. Concentricity controls the derived median points of a feature, and checking it to the standard means finding those points on a CMM, not reading a dial.
That exact question came to GD&T Basics from a viewer named Jeff, whose team had been treating concentricity as half the runout. In Using Runout to Measure Concentricity, Brandon walks through why that doesn't hold. Concentricity's tolerance zone is a cylinder around the datum axis, and the median points it checks come from pairs of probed points 180° apart. A runout reading is taken one cross-section at a time.
Runout vs Concentricity on a Real Part
The "half the runout" shortcut falls apart because of form error. An egg-shaped or lobed diameter can sit dead on center and still swing the indicator. A perfectly round diameter that's off-center swings it too. The dial can't tell you which one you've got.
The GD&T Basics concentricity reference says runout "can indirectly control concentricity and circularity simultaneously," and that runout only equals concentricity when the part is perfectly round. Turned parts never are, quite.
The same page notes concentricity was removed from ASME Y14.5 in the 2018 revision, and says runout or position should replace it in most cases.
Which One Should You Call Out?
For a diameter that spins in bearings or runs against a seal, runout is usually what you actually care about. It's checked in a minute with the part in V-blocks or a collet, and one reading catches both wobble and out-of-round.
Keep concentricity for the odd case where mass balance about the axis really matters and someone's willing to pay for CMM time to prove it. If an older drawing still carries it, a machinist will often run an indicator anyway as a sanity check. Brandon says he's done it himself, and that it works, but it isn't inspection to the standard.
Before adding either one, it's worth asking whether the callout is needed at all; what to do about overly tight tolerances covers that conversation. For bores that carry bearings, see how to tolerance a bearing housing bore. If you're not sure the part even belongs on a lathe, read turning vs milling.
Our CNC work defaults to ISO 2768-m, down to ±0.01 mm where the drawing calls for it. If you need a runout or concentricity callout inspected and reported, ask us when you quote.
Need a part made?
Upload your file for an instant price.