Symmetry Tolerance vs Position: Why Symmetry Was Dropped
A symmetry tolerance controls median points of a slot or tab, and ASME dropped it in 2018. How it differs from position and what to do with an old callout.
R. Dean Odell put a viewer question straight into his video title: GD&T symmetry vs position, is symmetry really that bad? If an older drawing lands on your desk with a symmetry tolerance on a slot or tab, here's what it asks for and why most people swap it for position.
Is GD&T Symmetry Really That Bad Compared to Position?
For most parts, yes. Symmetry was dropped from ASME Y14.5 in the 2018 revision, and position gives the same functional result on nearly every part while being far easier to inspect.
In GD&T Symmetry vs Position, Odell notes you can still use it on drawings made to the 2009 standard or earlier. Symmetry is meant for width features like slots and tabs. GD&T Basics calls it the non-circular version of concentricity. The tolerance zone is two parallel planes centered on the datum, same as position, but what has to land inside that zone is different.
How a Symmetry Tolerance Is Checked
Symmetry controls median points. You measure a point on one face, find the opposing point on the other face, take the midpoint, and repeat across the whole feature in three dimensions. Every midpoint has to fall in the zone. Odell says he has seen this done on a surface plate in illustrations but never in real life. The GD&T Basics page on symmetry says it usually takes a CMM scan and software to work out those midpoints.
Position looks at the center plane of the unrelated actual mating envelope, the pair of parallel planes that expand until they touch the high points. A void on one face doesn't move that center plane, as long as the feature stays within its size limits. Symmetry reacts to every bump. Odell's odd case: one bump pushes a median point out of tolerance, and a matching bump on the opposite face brings it back in.
What Position Adds
Position can be called at MMC, and so can its datum references. Symmetry is stuck at regardless of feature size. MMC opens up bonus tolerance, and GD&T Basics points out it lets position be checked with a gauge instead of a CMM run. Our posts on MMC bonus tolerance and plus-minus vs position cover that side. Odell says he has never seen a job that needed symmetry where position or profile couldn't do it, and GD&T Basics keeps it for rare mass-balance cases.
On Your Drawing
If you're on the 2018 standard, use position for a centered slot or tab. If a legacy symmetry callout has to stay, note which standard the drawing follows. Concentricity went out in the same revision, covered in runout vs concentricity. Our CNC page lists ISO 2768-m as standard and down to ±0.01 mm where the drawing calls for it, and every quote is reviewed by an engineer. If symmetry stays on the print, ask us when you quote how we'd inspect it.
Need a part made?
Upload your file for an instant price.