← All posts

Composite Position Tolerance: What the Lower Row Means

Composite position tolerance holds a hole pattern to itself in the lower row. When it matches two single-segment position and where the callouts differ.

A hole pattern for a cover plate rarely cares exactly where it sits on the part. It cares that the holes line up with each other. That's the job of a composite position tolerance, and the lower row of the frame is where people get tripped up.

Composite or Two Single-Segment Position With One Datum in the Lower Row?

With only the primary datum in the lower segment, composite and two single-segment position come out the same at inspection. The holes are located to each other and held perpendicular to datum A. The two callouts only split apart once the lower segment references a second datum.

That's R. Dean Odell's answer in GD&T Q&A: Composite vs Two Single Segment Position, Single Datum Reference, where he takes a viewer's question on exactly this case. He's clear that it's his reading of ASME Y14.5 and the references he checked, and he invites disagreement in the comments.

How a Composite Position Tolerance Works

His example is four holes held to .030 against the full A-B-C frame, with a lower segment of .010 to A. The upper row locates the pattern to the part. The lower row only holds the holes to each other, so the tight pattern can float around inside the bigger zones. He uses a light switch plate: the two screw holes have to match each other, and their height off the floor matters far less.

GD&T Basics on composite position spells out the rule. Datums in the lower row of a composite frame refine orientation only, never location, and they have to follow the same order as the top row. Add B to the lower row and the pattern still floats, it just can't rotate relative to B.

Where Two Single Segments Differ

Draw two separate position symbols and the lower row becomes its own full requirement. With B in it, the holes are now measured from B in translation as well as rotation. Odell describes the result as a slot-shaped zone, free to slide one way and locked the other. GD&T Basics shows the same thing, and the separate-segment version ends up tighter.

One trap from the video: position on top with perpendicularity underneath doesn't do this at all. Perpendicularity applies to each hole by itself, so nothing ties the holes to each other.

If position itself is new to you, start with plus/minus vs position and basic dimensions. For clearance holes, MMC bonus tolerance can loosen the lower row further.

Before You Send the Drawing

Our CNC standard is ISO 2768-m, down to ±0.01 mm where the drawing calls for it, and an engineer reviews every quote. If you need the pattern inspected and reported against a composite frame, ask us when you quote.

Need a part made?

Upload your file for an instant price.

Start a quote