Cylindricity vs Circularity: Which Form Callout to Use
Cylindricity vs circularity: circularity checks each slice of a round feature on its own, cylindricity holds the whole surface. When a shaft needs which.
A turned pin can measure round at every slice you check and still be tapered end to end. That gap is the whole cylindricity vs circularity question, and it decides whether a sliding fit binds halfway down.
How Do You Tolerance the Form of a Cylinder?
With cylindricity, if the whole surface has to be round and straight at once. Circularity only checks each cross-section on its own, so it can't catch taper or bow along the length.
Excedify puts the question plainly in CYLINDRICITY & CIRCULARITY: GD&T Explained Like You Are 5!: flatness handles a flat surface, so what if you want to tolerate a cylinder? Cylindricity gives two coaxial cylinders, 0.1 apart in their example, and every point on the real surface has to fall between them. Circularity cuts the feature at a plane and asks only that the slice fall between two concentric circles. Each slice is judged separately, with no relation to the next one. Neither control takes a datum, because form doesn't relate to anything else on the part.
Cylindricity vs Circularity on Real Parts
Circularity is the one that works on a cone, where cylindricity can't apply. In the video's example part, the long cylinder gets cylindricity while the cone and a short stub get circularity, since a short diameter doesn't have the length to vary much and there's no room to measure several sections.
GD&T Basics calls cylindricity a common callout when a part has to be both round and straight along its axis, like a sliding shaft or a dynamic locating pin. It's the 3D cousin of circularity in the same way flatness relates to straightness, which straightness vs flatness walks through. Their page also points out that Rule #1 means your size tolerance already limits form within the envelope at MMC, so a lot of shafts don't need either callout.
Two Drawing Mistakes the Video Calls Out
Don't put a diameter symbol in front of the value. The zone is a radial gap between two surfaces, not a diameter. And point the leader at the surface, not at the centerline, since a line can't be cylindrical.
If what you really care about is how a diameter spins on its bearings, that's runout, not form. Runout vs concentricity covers it, and bearing housing fit handles the size side of a bore.
Our CNC work runs to ISO 2768-m as standard, down to ±0.01 mm where the drawing calls for it. If you need cylindricity measured and reported on specific diameters, ask us when you quote.
Need a part made?
Upload your file for an instant price.