MJF Isotropy: Are Multi Jet Fusion Parts Weaker in Z?
MJF isotropy means near-equal strength in X, Y and Z, but HP's data shows lower Z elongation. What that means for snap fits, clips and build orientation.
HP posted a short clip that asks the question straight out: what is isotropy, and why does it matter? If you're designing a clip or a housing in MJF nylon, MJF isotropy decides how much you need to care which way the part sits in the build.
What Is MJF Isotropy and Why Does It Matter?
Isotropy means a part has the same mechanical properties in X, Y and Z. MJF nylon comes close on strength, but Z-direction elongation runs lower in HP's own data, so treat Z as the direction to check on parts that flex or snap.
In HP Multi Jet Fusion: What Is Isotropy and Why It Matters, HP's Aaron DeLong says layer-based processes are usually strong in the XY plane and get inconsistent bonding between layers in Z. He credits MJF's page-wide fusing with bonding each layer well to the one below. His sharper point is about design: without good isotropy, the only safe way to run FEA is to use the lowest value, the Z value, everywhere. That's a vendor talking about its own machine, so check it against numbers.
What the Data Shows
HP's own PA 12 datasheet (document 4AA6-4895ENE) lists tensile strength at 48 MPa in both XY and Z, with Z modulus slightly higher. Elongation at break is where it splits: 20% in XY against 15% in Z. Those come from HP's tests on ASTM D638 Type V bars.
Independent work is less tidy. A 2022 RMIT study in Polymers, Experimental Characterisation and Finite Element Modelling of Polyamide-12 Fabricated via Multi Jet Fusion, notes general disagreement in the literature on how print orientation affects MJF tensile properties. In their tests, parts oriented toward the vertical tended to come out with better tensile properties, which they put down to more complete fusion from extra passes of the heat source. So "Z is always weakest" isn't a safe rule for MJF either.
Designing Around It
For static parts, MJF nylon is close enough to isotropic in strength that orientation is usually picked for surface and accuracy. For snap fits and thin clips that bend, the lower Z elongation in HP's data is the number to respect, so keep the flexing direction in XY when you can. See PA11 vs PA12 for MJF snap fits for material choice and MJF Z-axis tolerance for the dimensional side. For SLS, our SLS part orientation post looked at a test where a tilted bar came out a few percent weaker.
On Your Part
Our 3D printing page lists HP Multi Jet Fusion in MJF Nylon, MJF Glass-Filled Nylon and MJF Nylon 11, held to ±0.3 mm or ±0.3%, whichever is greater. If a part has a direction that must flex or carry load, mark it on the drawing and ask us when you quote about build orientation.
Need a part made?
Upload your file for an instant price.