Spot Drill vs Center Drill: Which Starts a Hole Better?
A spot drill vs center drill test shows why the 60° center cone lets a twist drill grab and wander, when spotting helps, and when to skip it entirely.
KiwiCan Workshop's video on center drills vs spotting drills sets the spot drill vs center drill question up as a contest, then tests it with a dial indicator riding on the drill. The result is clearer than most shop arguments.
Center Drill or Spotting Drill: Which Is Better for Starting a Hole?
A spotting drill. A center drill's 60° cone is made for a lathe center to sit in, and a twist drill dropped into that cone touches on its cutting lips at the outer edge, where it can grab and get dragged off center.
In Center Drills vs Spotting Drills, the host starts with why a hole needs starting at all. A twist drill's chisel point is basically flat, so on a flat face it skates before it bites. A 1/4 in jobber drill also flexes. He pushed one about 20 thou with his thumb, while the center drill and spotting drill barely moved.
The spot works when its included angle matches or beats the drill's, such as a 120° spot under a 118° drill. Then the corners of the chisel touch first and the walls push the drill to center. When he fed the same jobber drill into a 60° center-drilled cone, it moved so far the indicator stylus lost contact, worse than with no spot at all. His home-shop workaround is to spot with only the small pilot tip of a center drill, which is ground at 118°.
Spot Drill vs Center Drill on a CNC Machine
CNCCookbook's spot drill guide agrees on the 60° problem and adds the other half. Carbide drills and short screw-machine-length drills usually don't need a spot, and most manufacturers advise against spotting a carbide drill because the dimple can chip it. Center drills still have one proper job: the 60° center hole for a tailstock or for turning between centers.
What It Means for Your Drawing
You won't pick the drill, but you control what the hole has to do. Location belongs in a tolerance, as in our post on tapped hole position tolerance. If you want an edge break at the hole entry, call out the chamfer, and check countersink angle if a screw head sits there. For long holes, straightness gets harder, as deep hole drilling explains. A shaft turned between centers can come back with center holes in its ends, so say so if those aren't acceptable.
What We'd Do on Your Part
Our CNC cell runs a Haas UMC-750 5-axis mill and a Haas DS-30Y lathe with live tooling, and the quote checks hole diameter and depth-to-diameter ratio automatically. If center holes on a shaft end matter to you, ask us when you quote.
Need a part made?
Upload your file for an instant price.