Thread Engagement: How Deep Should a Screw Go?
Thread engagement decides whether the screw breaks or the tapped hole strips. Why steel needs about one diameter of thread and aluminum needs more.
A tapped hole that strips at assembly usually wasn't tapped wrong. It was tapped too shallow for the material it's in. Thread engagement, the length of thread the screw actually shares with the hole, is the number that decides which part gives up first.
How Much Thread Engagement Do You Really Need?
Enough that the screw would break before the internal threads strip. In steel that usually lands around one screw diameter. In softer metals like aluminum, plan on more, often 1.5 to 2 diameters.
That's the answer Maker Garage 101 gives in How Much Thread Engagement Do You REALLY Need?, and the reasoning is worth more than the rule. Tightening stretches the screw, and that stretch is your clamp load. The internal threads don't stretch. They hold the pull in shear along their flanks, and every engaged thread adds a little more shear area. Once there's enough area to match the screw's strength, the video says, adding threads usually doesn't make the joint any stronger.
Why Aluminum Needs More Thread Engagement Than Steel
Same screw, weaker threads. Aluminum's internal threads strip more easily, so it takes more length to carry the same load. Nord-Lock's engineers put the common minimum at about 1x the nominal diameter in steel and 2x in aluminum. They're also blunt that softer materials and special alloys can need more, worked out by formula instead of rule of thumb.
Run their numbers on an M6 screw. In Aluminum 6061 the 2x rule asks for roughly 12 mm of full thread, where Mild Steel 1018 would usually be fine with about 6 mm.
Where the Rule Stops Working
The video lists the cases where a screw feels tight but the threads aren't doing the work: shallow holes, damaged threads, a screw bottoming out before it clamps, and a high-strength screw going into weaker material. Bottoming out catches designers more often than you'd think. A tap leaves incomplete threads at the bottom of a blind hole, so the drilled depth needs room past the engaged length. Tap drill depth covers how much.
Don't count on the torque wrench to warn you. The video closes on the point that torque doesn't tell you clamp load, so a joint can hit spec on the wrench while the threads are close to letting go.
Short on Depth?
If the wall won't allow 2x in aluminum, an insert gets strength back in less depth, and Helicoil inserts in aluminum goes through when that's worth paying for. Delrin and Nylon 6 hold threads worse still, so read threaded inserts in machined plastic before you tap one.
Our CNC quote costs threads as detected features, so a deeper tapped hole shows up as its own line. If you want inserts installed rather than plain tapped threads, ask us when you quote.
Need a part made?
Upload your file for an instant price.